U.S. Senators Visualized in 3D based on their votes

By Donald A. Smith

Using data from VoteView and software that I wrote, I made visualizations of U.S. senators based on their 2023 rollcall votes.

The visualizations use Principal Components Analysis (PCA) and tsne to project their voting data to 3d. Senators who voted the same on more bills/resolutions appear close together.
Votes of Senators who served only part of the term were omitted.


PCA (Principal Components Analysis) view:

Senate-PCA-1-with-captions.jpg

Below is another view of the same data, to make apparent the 3d rotation and to reveal more dimensions of the data. (The dimensions have no specific relation to, say, social or economic conservativism.)
Senate-PCA-2-with-captions.jpg

Those results are consistent with how Progressive Push ranks senators on a scale of conservatism/liberalism.. Progressive Push says Joe Manchin, Jon Tester, and Sherrod Brown are the most conservative Democratic senators.

By the way, Marie Gluesenkamp Perez (WA-CD8) is the second most conservative Democrat in the House (Jared Golden is the first), and Kim Schrier (WA-CD3) is the eighth most conservative Democrat, according to Progressive Push.

This view is using the TSNE projection:

Senate-tsne-with-captions.jpg


The senators whose votes were closest to each senator

The number in the first column is the vote distance between the senators based on the ~350 votes senators took in 2023. For example, the “6” on the line for DURBIN below the line For BALDWIN indicates that Tammy Baldwin and Richard Durbin voted the same on all but six votes in 2023.

BALDWIN, Tammy, Democrat (358 votes)
6:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)
7:   WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)
8:   VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  KLOBUCHAR, Amy(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)
9:   BROWN, Sherrod(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)  PETERS, Gary C.(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
10:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  KAINE, Timothy Michael (Tim)(Democrat)  CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  CARDIN, Benjamin Louis(Democrat)  MURPHY, Christopher(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  LUJÃ?N, Ben Ray(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  BENNET, Michael F.(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)


BENNET, Michael F., Democrat (357 votes)
4:   HICKENLOOPER, John Wright(Democrat)
5:   PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
6:   MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  KLOBUCHAR, Amy(Democrat)  KELLY, Mark Edward(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)
7:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie)(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  PETERS, Gary C.(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
8:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  KAINE, Timothy Michael (Tim)(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  LUJÃ?N, Ben Ray(Democrat)  HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)

BLACKBURN, Marsha, Republican (342 votes)
15:   HAGERTY, William Francis (Bill)(Republican)
17:   BRITT, Katie Elizabeth(Republican)
19:   JOHNSON, Ron(Republican)
22:   TUBERVILLE, Thomas Hawley (Tommy)(Republican)  SCOTT, Richard Lynn (Rick)(Republican)
23:   RISCH, James(Republican)

BLUMENTHAL, Richard, Democrat (358 votes)
1:   SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)
2:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
3:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
4:   VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  CARDIN, Benjamin Louis(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
5:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)

BOOKER, Cory Anthony, Democrat (341 votes)
6:   WYDEN, Ronald Lee(Democrat)
7:   WARREN, Elizabeth(Democrat)
8:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  HIRONO, Mazie(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  WELCH, Peter(Democrat)
9:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  CARDIN, Benjamin Louis(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  MERKLEY, Jeff(Democrat)
10:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  MARKEY, Edward John(Democrat)  LUJÃ?N, Ben Ray(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)

BOOZMAN, John, Republican (352 votes)
13:   COTTON, Tom(Republican)
18:   FISCHER, Debra (Deb)(Republican)
21:   HYDE-SMITH, Cindy(Republican)  THUNE, John(Republican)
23:   ERNST, Joni(Republican)
25:   WICKER, Roger F.(Republican)

BRAUN, Michael, Republican (349 votes)
23:   HAWLEY, Joshua David(Republican)  SCHMITT, Eric Stephen(Republican)
26:   LEE, Mike(Republican)
30:   TUBERVILLE, Thomas Hawley (Tommy)(Republican)  VANCE, James David(Republican)
33:   LUMMIS, Cynthia M.(Republican)
34:   SCOTT, Richard Lynn (Rick)(Republican)  MARSHALL, Roger Wayne(Republican)

BRITT, Katie Elizabeth, Republican (352 votes)
17:   BLACKBURN, Marsha(Republican)
18:   HAGERTY, William Francis (Bill)(Republican)
20:   FISCHER, Debra (Deb)(Republican)
21:   COTTON, Tom(Republican)
22:   HYDE-SMITH, Cindy(Republican)

BROWN, Sherrod, Democrat (355 votes)
5:   CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)
6:   PETERS, Gary C.(Democrat)
7:   KELLY, Mark Edward(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)
8:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie)(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  KLOBUCHAR, Amy(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
9:   BALDWIN, Tammy(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  BENNET, Michael F.(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)

BUDD, Theodore Paul, Republican (347 votes)
22:   COTTON, Tom(Republican)
24:   CRUZ, Rafael Edward (Ted)(Republican)  JOHNSON, Ron(Republican)
25:   DAINES, Steve(Republican)
26:   LUMMIS, Cynthia M.(Republican)
27:   BLACKBURN, Marsha(Republican)


CANTWELL, Maria E., Democrat (354 votes)
2:   WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)
3:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
4:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
5:   VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  LUJÃ?N, Ben Ray(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
6:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  HICKENLOOPER, John Wright(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)

CAPITO, Shelley Moore, Republican (352 votes)
24:   ROMNEY, Willard Mitt (Mitt)(Republican)
26:   ROUNDS, Marion Michael (Mike)(Republican)
29:   CORNYN, John(Republican)  McCONNELL, Addison Mitchell (Mitch)(Republican)
34:   WICKER, Roger F.(Republican)
37:   BOOZMAN, John(Republican)

CARDIN, Benjamin Louis, Democrat (352 votes)
4:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)
5:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)
6:   VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  MURPHY, Christopher(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
7:   PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
8:   HIRONO, Mazie(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)

CARPER, Thomas Richard, Democrat (358 votes)
1:   WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)
2:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
3:   PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
4:   WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
5:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  CARDIN, Benjamin Louis(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  PETERS, Gary C.(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)

CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr., Democrat (343 votes)
1:   PETERS, Gary C.(Democrat)
2:   COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
3:   MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie)(Democrat)
4:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
5:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  BROWN, Sherrod(Democrat)  CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  HICKENLOOPER, John Wright(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  KLOBUCHAR, Amy(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  BENNET, Michael F.(Democrat)

CASSIDY, Bill, Republican (344 votes)
35:   CRAMER, Kevin(Republican)
41:   HYDE-SMITH, Cindy(Republican)
43:   LANKFORD, James(Republican)
44:   MORAN, Jerry(Republican)
45:   COTTON, Tom(Republican)  HAGERTY, William Francis (Bill)(Republican)  YOUNG, Todd(Republican)  HOEVEN, John(Republican)

COLLINS, Susan Margaret, Republican (361 votes)
30:   MURKOWSKI, Lisa(Republican)
64:   MANCHIN, Joe, III(Democrat)
71:   GRAHAM, Lindsey O.(Republican)
91:   TESTER, Jon(Democrat)
95:   KING, Angus Stanley, Jr.(Independent)  SINEMA, Kyrsten(Independent)

COONS, Christopher A., Democrat (342 votes)
0:   MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)
1:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
2:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)
3:   CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
4:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie)(Democrat)  HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)  PETERS, Gary C.(Democrat)

CORNYN, John, Republican (351 votes)
29:   CAPITO, Shelley Moore(Republican)  ROMNEY, Willard Mitt (Mitt)(Republican)
31:   WICKER, Roger F.(Republican)
32:   LANKFORD, James(Republican)
34:   HYDE-SMITH, Cindy(Republican)  McCONNELL, Addison Mitchell (Mitch)(Republican)
36:   ERNST, Joni(Republican)

CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie, Democrat (360 votes)
4:   COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
5:   HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie)(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)
6:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  HICKENLOOPER, John Wright(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  KLOBUCHAR, Amy(Democrat)  LUJÃ?N, Ben Ray(Democrat)  HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  BENNET, Michael F.(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
7:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  PETERS, Gary C.(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
8:   KAINE, Timothy Michael (Tim)(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  KELLY, Mark Edward(Democrat)

COTTON, Tom, Republican (349 votes)
13:   BOOZMAN, John(Republican)
15:   FISCHER, Debra (Deb)(Republican)
19:   HYDE-SMITH, Cindy(Republican)  LANKFORD, James(Republican)
21:   HAGERTY, William Francis (Bill)(Republican)  MULLIN, Markwayne(Republican)  BRITT, Katie Elizabeth(Republican)
22:   BUDD, Theodore Paul(Republican)  ERNST, Joni(Republican)

CRAMER, Kevin, Republican (327 votes)
23:   HOEVEN, John(Republican)
24:   THUNE, John(Republican)
26:   FISCHER, Debra (Deb)(Republican)
28:   COTTON, Tom(Republican)  BOOZMAN, John(Republican)
29:   ERNST, Joni(Republican)  LANKFORD, James(Republican)

CRAPO, Michael Dean, Republican (344 votes)
1:   RISCH, James(Republican)
27:   BLACKBURN, Marsha(Republican)
30:   COTTON, Tom(Republican)  CRUZ, Rafael Edward (Ted)(Republican)  JOHNSON, Ron(Republican)
31:   HAGERTY, William Francis (Bill)(Republican)
32:   MULLIN, Markwayne(Republican)  BRITT, Katie Elizabeth(Republican)

CRUZ, Rafael Edward (Ted), Republican (327 votes)
21:   JOHNSON, Ron(Republican)
22:   HAGERTY, William Francis (Bill)(Republican)
24:   FISCHER, Debra (Deb)(Republican)  BUDD, Theodore Paul(Republican)
25:   COTTON, Tom(Republican)
27:   RISCH, James(Republican)  BRITT, Katie Elizabeth(Republican)  DAINES, Steve(Republican)

DAINES, Steve, Republican (349 votes)
20:   HAGERTY, William Francis (Bill)(Republican)
23:   JOHNSON, Ron(Republican)
25:   BUDD, Theodore Paul(Republican)
26:   LUMMIS, Cynthia M.(Republican)  MARSHALL, Roger Wayne(Republican)
27:   CRUZ, Rafael Edward (Ted)(Republican)  FISCHER, Debra (Deb)(Republican)

DUCKWORTH, Tammy, Democrat (354 votes)
0:   WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)
1:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)
2:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
3:   PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
4:   VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  CARDIN, Benjamin Louis(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)

DURBIN, Richard Joseph, Democrat (319 votes)
2:   MURPHY, Christopher(Democrat)
3:   WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)
4:   VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  CARDIN, Benjamin Louis(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
5:   MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  PETERS, Gary C.(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
6:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  BALDWIN, Tammy(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  HIRONO, Mazie(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)

ERNST, Joni, Republican (349 votes)
16:   FISCHER, Debra (Deb)(Republican)
22:   COTTON, Tom(Republican)
23:   BOOZMAN, John(Republican)
24:   WICKER, Roger F.(Republican)
25:   THUNE, John(Republican)



FISCHER, Debra (Deb), Republican (358 votes)
15:   COTTON, Tom(Republican)
16:   HAGERTY, William Francis (Bill)(Republican)  ERNST, Joni(Republican)
18:   BOOZMAN, John(Republican)
20:   BRITT, Katie Elizabeth(Republican)
21:   LANKFORD, James(Republican)

GILLIBRAND, Kirsten, Democrat (354 votes)
2:   SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
3:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
4:   CARDIN, Benjamin Louis(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
5:   CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)
6:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  KAINE, Timothy Michael (Tim)(Democrat)  CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  MURPHY, Christopher(Democrat)  KLOBUCHAR, Amy(Democrat)  HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)

GRAHAM, Lindsey O., Republican (339 votes)
68:   TILLIS, Thomas Roland (Thom)(Republican)
71:   COLLINS, Susan Margaret(Republican)
73:   MURKOWSKI, Lisa(Republican)
83:   MANCHIN, Joe, III(Democrat)
92:   McCONNELL, Addison Mitchell (Mitch)(Republican)

GRASSLEY, Charles Ernest, Republican (356 votes)
42:   McCONNELL, Addison Mitchell (Mitch)(Republican)
45:   MORAN, Jerry(Republican)
46:   CORNYN, John(Republican)  CRAMER, Kevin(Republican)
50:   ROMNEY, Willard Mitt (Mitt)(Republican)
51:   YOUNG, Todd(Republican)  CAPITO, Shelley Moore(Republican)

HAGERTY, William Francis (Bill), Republican (332 votes)
15:   BLACKBURN, Marsha(Republican)
16:   FISCHER, Debra (Deb)(Republican)
18:   BRITT, Katie Elizabeth(Republican)
20:   JOHNSON, Ron(Republican)  DAINES, Steve(Republican)
21:   COTTON, Tom(Republican)

HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie), Democrat (360 votes)
3:   CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
4:   COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)  PETERS, Gary C.(Democrat)
5:   MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)
6:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  KING, Angus Stanley, Jr.(Independent)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
7:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  KAINE, Timothy Michael (Tim)(Democrat)  HICKENLOOPER, John Wright(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  KLOBUCHAR, Amy(Democrat)  KELLY, Mark Edward(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  BENNET, Michael F.(Democrat)

HAWLEY, Joshua David, Republican (342 votes)
9:   SCHMITT, Eric Stephen(Republican)
22:   SCOTT, Richard Lynn (Rick)(Republican)
23:   BRAUN, Michael(Republican)
28:   LUMMIS, Cynthia M.(Republican)
29:   TUBERVILLE, Thomas Hawley (Tommy)(Republican)  LEE, Mike(Republican)  VANCE, James David(Republican)

HEINRICH, Martin, Democrat (355 votes)
3:   WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)
4:   LUJÃ?N, Ben Ray(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
5:   WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)
6:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
7:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  CARDIN, Benjamin Louis(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)

HICKENLOOPER, John Wright, Democrat (348 votes)
4:   BENNET, Michael F.(Democrat)
5:   CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
6:   MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)
7:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie)(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  PETERS, Gary C.(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
8:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  KING, Angus Stanley, Jr.(Independent)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  KLOBUCHAR, Amy(Democrat)  LUJÃ?N, Ben Ray(Democrat)  HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)  KELLY, Mark Edward(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)

HIRONO, Mazie, Democrat (361 votes)
4:   VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)
6:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)
7:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
8:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  BOOKER, Cory Anthony(Democrat)  CARDIN, Benjamin Louis(Democrat)  MURPHY, Christopher(Democrat)  HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)
9:   STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)

HOEVEN, John, Republican (353 votes)
21:   THUNE, John(Republican)
23:   CRAMER, Kevin(Republican)
24:   HAGERTY, William Francis (Bill)(Republican)
25:   BRITT, Katie Elizabeth(Republican)
26:   BLACKBURN, Marsha(Republican)

HYDE-SMITH, Cindy, Republican (349 votes)
19:   COTTON, Tom(Republican)
21:   BOOZMAN, John(Republican)
22:   BRITT, Katie Elizabeth(Republican)  LANKFORD, James(Republican)
23:   FISCHER, Debra (Deb)(Republican)  HAGERTY, William Francis (Bill)(Republican)
24:   WICKER, Roger F.(Republican)

JOHNSON, Ron, Republican (349 votes)
19:   BLACKBURN, Marsha(Republican)
20:   HAGERTY, William Francis (Bill)(Republican)
21:   CRUZ, Rafael Edward (Ted)(Republican)
23:   DAINES, Steve(Republican)
24:   BUDD, Theodore Paul(Republican)  TUBERVILLE, Thomas Hawley (Tommy)(Republican)  SCOTT, Richard Lynn (Rick)(Republican)  BRITT, Katie Elizabeth(Republican)

KAINE, Timothy Michael (Tim), Democrat (360 votes)
4:   PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
5:   WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
6:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  KLOBUCHAR, Amy(Democrat)  KELLY, Mark Edward(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)
7:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie)(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
8:   KING, Angus Stanley, Jr.(Independent)  CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)  BENNET, Michael F.(Democrat)

KELLY, Mark Edward, Democrat (343 votes)
5:   PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
6:   MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  KAINE, Timothy Michael (Tim)(Democrat)  BENNET, Michael F.(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
7:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  BROWN, Sherrod(Democrat)  HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie)(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
8:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  HICKENLOOPER, John Wright(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  KLOBUCHAR, Amy(Democrat)  HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)
9:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  PETERS, Gary C.(Democrat)

KENNEDY, John Neely, Republican (351 votes)
38:   McCONNELL, Addison Mitchell (Mitch)(Republican)
45:   HYDE-SMITH, Cindy(Republican)
47:   COTTON, Tom(Republican)  CRAMER, Kevin(Republican)
50:   BOOZMAN, John(Republican)  MULLIN, Markwayne(Republican)
51:   CORNYN, John(Republican)  CAPITO, Shelley Moore(Republican)

KING, Angus Stanley, Jr., Independent (349 votes)
6:   HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie)(Democrat)
7:   SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
8:   KAINE, Timothy Michael (Tim)(Democrat)  HICKENLOOPER, John Wright(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
9:   MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)
10:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  PETERS, Gary C.(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)

KLOBUCHAR, Amy, Democrat (357 votes)
5:   SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
6:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  KAINE, Timothy Michael (Tim)(Democrat)  CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  BENNET, Michael F.(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
7:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie)(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  PETERS, Gary C.(Democrat)
8:   BALDWIN, Tammy(Democrat)  BROWN, Sherrod(Democrat)  HICKENLOOPER, John Wright(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  LUJÃ?N, Ben Ray(Democrat)  HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)  KELLY, Mark Edward(Democrat)
9:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)

LANKFORD, James, Republican (359 votes)
19:   COTTON, Tom(Republican)
20:   RUBIO, Marco(Republican)
21:   FISCHER, Debra (Deb)(Republican)
22:   HYDE-SMITH, Cindy(Republican)
26:   HAGERTY, William Francis (Bill)(Republican)  MULLIN, Markwayne(Republican)  ERNST, Joni(Republican)

LEE, Mike, Republican (337 votes)
26:   BRAUN, Michael(Republican)
27:   PAUL, Rand(Republican)
28:   SCHMITT, Eric Stephen(Republican)
29:   HAWLEY, Joshua David(Republican)  VANCE, James David(Republican)
35:   TUBERVILLE, Thomas Hawley (Tommy)(Republican)

LUJÃ?N, Ben Ray, Democrat (358 votes)
4:   HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)
5:   WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)
6:   CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
7:   WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)
8:   VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  HICKENLOOPER, John Wright(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  KLOBUCHAR, Amy(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  BENNET, Michael F.(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)

LUMMIS, Cynthia M., Republican (348 votes)
26:   BUDD, Theodore Paul(Republican)  DAINES, Steve(Republican)
28:   CRUZ, Rafael Edward (Ted)(Republican)  HAWLEY, Joshua David(Republican)
29:   TUBERVILLE, Thomas Hawley (Tommy)(Republican)
30:   JOHNSON, Ron(Republican)
32:   FISCHER, Debra (Deb)(Republican)  SCOTT, Richard Lynn (Rick)(Republican)

MANCHIN, Joe, III, Democrat (353 votes)
60:   TESTER, Jon(Democrat)
63:   KING, Angus Stanley, Jr.(Independent)
64:   COLLINS, Susan Margaret(Republican)
66:   SINEMA, Kyrsten(Independent)
67:   PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)

MARKEY, Edward John, Democrat (350 votes)
3:   WARREN, Elizabeth(Democrat)
6:   SANDERS, Bernard(Independent)  WELCH, Peter(Democrat)
7:   MERKLEY, Jeff(Democrat)
10:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  BOOKER, Cory Anthony(Democrat)
12:   WYDEN, Ronald Lee(Democrat)

MARSHALL, Roger Wayne, Republican (345 votes)
26:   DAINES, Steve(Republican)
29:   HAGERTY, William Francis (Bill)(Republican)  SCHMITT, Eric Stephen(Republican)
31:   BLACKBURN, Marsha(Republican)
32:   CRUZ, Rafael Edward (Ted)(Republican)  TUBERVILLE, Thomas Hawley (Tommy)(Republican)  BRITT, Katie Elizabeth(Republican)
33:   LUMMIS, Cynthia M.(Republican)  JOHNSON, Ron(Republican)

MENENDEZ, Robert, Democrat (354 votes)
6:   PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)
7:   CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)
8:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
9:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie)(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
10:   VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  KAINE, Timothy Michael (Tim)(Democrat)  CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  KLOBUCHAR, Amy(Democrat)  LUJÃ?N, Ben Ray(Democrat)  HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)

MERKLEY, Jeff, Democrat (346 votes)
6:   WELCH, Peter(Democrat)
7:   MARKEY, Edward John(Democrat)
8:   WYDEN, Ronald Lee(Democrat)
9:   WARREN, Elizabeth(Democrat)  BOOKER, Cory Anthony(Democrat)
11:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  SANDERS, Bernard(Independent)

MORAN, Jerry, Republican (329 votes)
26:   YOUNG, Todd(Republican)
30:   CRAMER, Kevin(Republican)
34:   BOOZMAN, John(Republican)
36:   THUNE, John(Republican)
37:   McCONNELL, Addison Mitchell (Mitch)(Republican)

MULLIN, Markwayne, Republican (346 votes)
21:   COTTON, Tom(Republican)
24:   BRITT, Katie Elizabeth(Republican)
25:   HYDE-SMITH, Cindy(Republican)  FISCHER, Debra (Deb)(Republican)
26:   LANKFORD, James(Republican)
27:   BOOZMAN, John(Republican)  RUBIO, Marco(Republican)

MURKOWSKI, Lisa, Republican (348 votes)
30:   COLLINS, Susan Margaret(Republican)
73:   GRAHAM, Lindsey O.(Republican)
79:   MANCHIN, Joe, III(Democrat)
95:   TILLIS, Thomas Roland (Thom)(Republican)
100:   TESTER, Jon(Democrat)

MURPHY, Christopher, Democrat (360 votes)
2:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)
5:   WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)
6:   VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CARDIN, Benjamin Louis(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)
7:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
8:   MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  HIRONO, Mazie(Democrat)  WELCH, Peter(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)

MURRAY, Patty, Democrat (354 votes)
0:   COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
1:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
2:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)
3:   WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)
4:   OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)

McCONNELL, Addison Mitchell (Mitch), Republican (329 votes)
28:   WICKER, Roger F.(Republican)
29:   YOUNG, Todd(Republican)  CAPITO, Shelley Moore(Republican)
33:   TILLIS, Thomas Roland (Thom)(Republican)
34:   CORNYN, John(Republican)  ROMNEY, Willard Mitt (Mitt)(Republican)  ROUNDS, Marion Michael (Mike)(Republican)
36:   HYDE-SMITH, Cindy(Republican)

OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon), Democrat (353 votes)
2:   COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
4:   MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)
5:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
6:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  KAINE, Timothy Michael (Tim)(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
7:   HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie)(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  PETERS, Gary C.(Democrat)

PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex), Democrat (336 votes)
1:   MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
2:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
3:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)
4:   KAINE, Timothy Michael (Tim)(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
5:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie)(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  KELLY, Mark Edward(Democrat)  BENNET, Michael F.(Democrat)

PAUL, Rand, Republican (346 votes)
27:   LEE, Mike(Republican)
35:   BRAUN, Michael(Republican)
37:   HAWLEY, Joshua David(Republican)  SCHMITT, Eric Stephen(Republican)
38:   VANCE, James David(Republican)
44:   TUBERVILLE, Thomas Hawley (Tommy)(Republican)

PETERS, Gary C., Democrat (358 votes)
1:   CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)
4:   HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie)(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
5:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
6:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  BROWN, Sherrod(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)
7:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  HICKENLOOPER, John Wright(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  KLOBUCHAR, Amy(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  BENNET, Michael F.(Democrat)

REED, John F. (Jack), Democrat (361 votes)
1:   MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
2:   PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
3:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)
4:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)
5:   VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  CARDIN, Benjamin Louis(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)

RICKETTS, John Peter (Pete), Republican (353 votes)
22:   FISCHER, Debra (Deb)(Republican)
27:   COTTON, Tom(Republican)
29:   ERNST, Joni(Republican)
30:   RISCH, James(Republican)
32:   BOOZMAN, John(Republican)

RISCH, James, Republican (322 votes)
1:   CRAPO, Michael Dean(Republican)
23:   BLACKBURN, Marsha(Republican)
26:   SCOTT, Richard Lynn (Rick)(Republican)
27:   CRUZ, Rafael Edward (Ted)(Republican)  JOHNSON, Ron(Republican)  BRITT, Katie Elizabeth(Republican)
28:   COTTON, Tom(Republican)  HAGERTY, William Francis (Bill)(Republican)  MULLIN, Markwayne(Republican)

ROMNEY, Willard Mitt (Mitt), Republican (348 votes)
24:   CAPITO, Shelley Moore(Republican)
29:   CORNYN, John(Republican)
34:   ROUNDS, Marion Michael (Mike)(Republican)  McCONNELL, Addison Mitchell (Mitch)(Republican)
39:   YOUNG, Todd(Republican)
41:   BOOZMAN, John(Republican)

ROSEN, Jacklyn Sheryl, Democrat (361 votes)
11:   CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
14:   HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie)(Democrat)
15:   KAINE, Timothy Michael (Tim)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  KLOBUCHAR, Amy(Democrat)  KELLY, Mark Edward(Democrat)  BENNET, Michael F.(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
16:   WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)
17:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  HICKENLOOPER, John Wright(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  LUJÃ?N, Ben Ray(Democrat)  HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)

ROUNDS, Marion Michael (Mike), Republican (351 votes)
26:   CAPITO, Shelley Moore(Republican)
34:   ROMNEY, Willard Mitt (Mitt)(Republican)  McCONNELL, Addison Mitchell (Mitch)(Republican)
42:   TILLIS, Thomas Roland (Thom)(Republican)
46:   CORNYN, John(Republican)
47:   MORAN, Jerry(Republican)

RUBIO, Marco, Republican (343 votes)
20:   LANKFORD, James(Republican)
25:   HAGERTY, William Francis (Bill)(Republican)
26:   BLACKBURN, Marsha(Republican)
27:   COTTON, Tom(Republican)  HYDE-SMITH, Cindy(Republican)  JOHNSON, Ron(Republican)  MULLIN, Markwayne(Republican)
28:   FISCHER, Debra (Deb)(Republican)

SANDERS, Bernard, Independent (324 votes)
6:   MARKEY, Edward John(Democrat)
10:   WARREN, Elizabeth(Democrat)
11:   MERKLEY, Jeff(Democrat)
13:   WELCH, Peter(Democrat)
14:   BOOKER, Cory Anthony(Democrat)

SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel, Democrat (351 votes)
1:   MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
2:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
3:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)
4:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)
5:   OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  CARDIN, Benjamin Louis(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)

SCHMITT, Eric Stephen, Republican (348 votes)
9:   HAWLEY, Joshua David(Republican)
22:   SCOTT, Richard Lynn (Rick)(Republican)
23:   BRAUN, Michael(Republican)
28:   LEE, Mike(Republican)
29:   TUBERVILLE, Thomas Hawley (Tommy)(Republican)  MARSHALL, Roger Wayne(Republican)

SCHUMER, Charles Ellis (Chuck), Democrat (358 votes)
5:   MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
6:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
7:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)
8:   OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)
9:   WARNER, Mark(Democrat)

SCOTT, Richard Lynn (Rick), Republican (349 votes)
18:   TUBERVILLE, Thomas Hawley (Tommy)(Republican)
22:   HAWLEY, Joshua David(Republican)  BLACKBURN, Marsha(Republican)  SCHMITT, Eric Stephen(Republican)
24:   JOHNSON, Ron(Republican)
26:   RISCH, James(Republican)  HAGERTY, William Francis (Bill)(Republican)  BRITT, Katie Elizabeth(Republican)
29:   CRUZ, Rafael Edward (Ted)(Republican)


SHAHEEN, Jeanne, Democrat (349 votes)
3:   MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
4:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
5:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  PETERS, Gary C.(Democrat)
6:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  KAINE, Timothy Michael (Tim)(Democrat)  CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  KLOBUCHAR, Amy(Democrat)  KELLY, Mark Edward(Democrat)  BENNET, Michael F.(Democrat)
7:   BROWN, Sherrod(Democrat)  KING, Angus Stanley, Jr.(Independent)

SINEMA, Kyrsten, Independent (359 votes)
16:   TESTER, Jon(Democrat)
20:   KING, Angus Stanley, Jr.(Independent)  ROSEN, Jacklyn Sheryl(Democrat)
22:   HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie)(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
23:   CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  HICKENLOOPER, John Wright(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  BENNET, Michael F.(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
25:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  KAINE, Timothy Michael (Tim)(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  KELLY, Mark Edward(Democrat)

SMITH, Tina, Democrat (352 votes)
2:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
3:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
4:   VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
5:   KLOBUCHAR, Amy(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)
6:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  KAINE, Timothy Michael (Tim)(Democrat)  CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  CARDIN, Benjamin Louis(Democrat)  MURPHY, Christopher(Democrat)  HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)

STABENOW, Deborah Ann, Democrat (348 votes)
1:   MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
2:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)
3:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)
4:   WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  PETERS, Gary C.(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)
5:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)

SULLIVAN, Daniel Scott, Republican (345 votes)
32:   BRITT, Katie Elizabeth(Republican)
35:   HOEVEN, John(Republican)  SCOTT, Richard Lynn (Rick)(Republican)
36:   FISCHER, Debra (Deb)(Republican)
37:   HAGERTY, William Francis (Bill)(Republican)  BLACKBURN, Marsha(Republican)
38:   COTTON, Tom(Republican)  RISCH, James(Republican)  THUNE, John(Republican)

TESTER, Jon, Democrat (361 votes)
16:   SINEMA, Kyrsten(Independent)
17:   KING, Angus Stanley, Jr.(Independent)
18:   BROWN, Sherrod(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
19:   CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  HICKENLOOPER, John Wright(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  BENNET, Michael F.(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)
20:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie)(Democrat)  PETERS, Gary C.(Democrat)

THUNE, John, Republican (361 votes)
21:   BOOZMAN, John(Republican)  HOEVEN, John(Republican)
24:   COTTON, Tom(Republican)  CRAMER, Kevin(Republican)
25:   ERNST, Joni(Republican)
26:   FISCHER, Debra (Deb)(Republican)
28:   MULLIN, Markwayne(Republican)  BRITT, Katie Elizabeth(Republican)

TILLIS, Thomas Roland (Thom), Republican (320 votes)
33:   McCONNELL, Addison Mitchell (Mitch)(Republican)
42:   ROUNDS, Marion Michael (Mike)(Republican)
43:   CAPITO, Shelley Moore(Republican)
44:   ROMNEY, Willard Mitt (Mitt)(Republican)
45:   YOUNG, Todd(Republican)

TUBERVILLE, Thomas Hawley (Tommy), Republican (339 votes)
18:   SCOTT, Richard Lynn (Rick)(Republican)
22:   BLACKBURN, Marsha(Republican)
23:   HAGERTY, William Francis (Bill)(Republican)
24:   JOHNSON, Ron(Republican)
25:   BRITT, Katie Elizabeth(Republican)

VAN HOLLEN, Christopher, Democrat (359 votes)
4:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  HIRONO, Mazie(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)
5:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
6:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  CARDIN, Benjamin Louis(Democrat)  MURPHY, Christopher(Democrat)  HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)
7:   PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
8:   BALDWIN, Tammy(Democrat)  BOOKER, Cory Anthony(Democrat)  LUJÃ?N, Ben Ray(Democrat)  WELCH, Peter(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)

VANCE, James David, Republican (346 votes)
29:   LEE, Mike(Republican)  HAWLEY, Joshua David(Republican)
30:   BRAUN, Michael(Republican)
32:   SCHMITT, Eric Stephen(Republican)
35:   MARSHALL, Roger Wayne(Republican)
37:   JOHNSON, Ron(Republican)

WARNER, Mark, Democrat (356 votes)
3:   HASSAN, Margaret (Maggie)(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
4:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  KAINE, Timothy Michael (Tim)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)
5:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  PETERS, Gary C.(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
6:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  KLOBUCHAR, Amy(Democrat)  HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)  KELLY, Mark Edward(Democrat)
7:   KING, Angus Stanley, Jr.(Independent)

WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel, Democrat (351 votes)
1:   WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)
2:   CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
3:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  HEINRICH, Martin(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
4:   VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
5:   KAINE, Timothy Michael (Tim)(Democrat)  CORTEZ MASTO, Catherine Marie(Democrat)  OSSOFF, Thomas Jonathan (Jon)(Democrat)  KLOBUCHAR, Amy(Democrat)  LUJÃ?N, Ben Ray(Democrat)  SHAHEEN, Jeanne(Democrat)

WARREN, Elizabeth, Democrat (359 votes)
3:   MARKEY, Edward John(Democrat)
7:   BOOKER, Cory Anthony(Democrat)  WELCH, Peter(Democrat)
9:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  WYDEN, Ronald Lee(Democrat)  MERKLEY, Jeff(Democrat)
10:   SANDERS, Bernard(Independent)
11:   VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)

WELCH, Peter, Democrat (352 votes)
6:   MARKEY, Edward John(Democrat)  MERKLEY, Jeff(Democrat)
7:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  WARREN, Elizabeth(Democrat)
8:   VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  BOOKER, Cory Anthony(Democrat)  MURPHY, Christopher(Democrat)  WYDEN, Ronald Lee(Democrat)
10:   HIRONO, Mazie(Democrat)
12:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CARDIN, Benjamin Louis(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)

WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon, Democrat (351 votes)
0:   DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)
1:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)
2:   GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
3:   PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)  WARNER, Mark(Democrat)
4:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  CARDIN, Benjamin Louis(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)

WICKER, Roger F., Republican (358 votes)
23:   FISCHER, Debra (Deb)(Republican)
24:   HYDE-SMITH, Cindy(Republican)  ERNST, Joni(Republican)
25:   BOOZMAN, John(Republican)
28:   McCONNELL, Addison Mitchell (Mitch)(Republican)
29:   THUNE, John(Republican)

WYDEN, Ronald Lee, Democrat (360 votes)
6:   BOOKER, Cory Anthony(Democrat)
8:   DURBIN, Richard Joseph(Democrat)  SMITH, Tina(Democrat)  WELCH, Peter(Democrat)  MERKLEY, Jeff(Democrat)
9:   WARREN, Elizabeth(Democrat)  WARNOCK, Raphael Gamaliel(Democrat)  CANTWELL, Maria E.(Democrat)  STABENOW, Deborah Ann(Democrat)
10:   VAN HOLLEN, Christopher(Democrat)  GILLIBRAND, Kirsten(Democrat)  MURRAY, Patty(Democrat)  CARPER, Thomas Richard(Democrat)  WHITEHOUSE, Sheldon(Democrat)  LUJÃ?N, Ben Ray(Democrat)  CASEY, Robert (Bob), Jr.(Democrat)  BLUMENTHAL, Richard(Democrat)  DUCKWORTH, Tammy(Democrat)  COONS, Christopher A.(Democrat)
11:   REED, John F. (Jack)(Democrat)  PADILLA, Alejandro (Alex)(Democrat)  SCHATZ, Brian Emanuel(Democrat)

YOUNG, Todd, Republican (354 votes)
26:   MORAN, Jerry(Republican)
29:   McCONNELL, Addison Mitchell (Mitch)(Republican)
37:   CRAMER, Kevin(Republican)
39:   ROMNEY, Willard Mitt (Mitt)(Republican)
43:   CAPITO, Shelley Moore(Republican)