GOP Tax Plan: raise taxes on the middle class, students and the elderly, so the rich can get yet more tax breaks

The GOP Plan Is the Biggest Tax Increase in American History, By Far

The big deficits in GOP tax plan aren’t a glitch — they’re the whole point. “Slashing taxes is going to cause big budget deficits. But the reason Republicans don’t really care is because they can use the resulting fiscal crisis to go after Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security.”

White House Says Cutting Meals on Wheels Is ‘Compassionate’

To pay for tax cuts for billionaires, the US Senate just repealed the credit for elderly and the permanently disabled.

GOP Tax Scam

  • Both the House and Senate bills dramatically lower the federal deduction for state and local taxes (SALT), making it tougher to raise funds for public schools. That means that you will be taxed on part of your income that was already taxed to support public schools.
  • The House bill also eliminates the tax deduction for student loan interest, taxes tuition waivers as income, and eliminates the small tax credit for teachers to buy school supplies.

Pray before raping

The could have added: “destroying the environment, deregulating Wall Street, making it harder for minorities to vote, damaging the neutrality of the Internet, concentrating media ownership in Trump-friendly corporations, reversing the New Deal, squashing unions, supporting neo-Nazis,” etc.

Who funded Washington State campaigns and initiatives in 2016 and 2017?

I downloaded from the Washington State Public Disclosure Commission a spreadsheet listing contributions to political campaigns and initiatives. After loading it into a database, I ran some queries to see who’s spending the most.

Over $60 million was donated to campaigns and initiatives in 2017, according to the PDC data.

In 2016, over $144 million was spent.

MariaDB [contributions]> select sum(Amount) from contrib where `Receipt date` >= '2017-01-01';
+-------------+
| sum(Amount) |
+-------------+
| 60918944.17 |
+-------------+
1 row in set (0.85 sec)

MariaDB [contributions]> select sum(Amount) from contrib where `Receipt date` >= '2016-01-01' and `Receipt date` < '2017-01-01';
+--------------+
| sum(Amount)  |
+--------------+
| 144721261.22 |
+--------------+
1 row in set (1.29 sec)

2017 biggest spenders

Notice that you generally can’t tell from the names who’s paying for it — the individual contributors are hidden — and what they’re trying to buy. Stand for Children, Inc, which has the largest entry, is a pro-charter schools PAC funded by Connie Ballmer, among others.

Eastside Leadership Council (a pro-Manka Dhingra group) donated numerous times, for a total of $1,345,000. Here’s their facebook page.

Likewise, Working Families donated a total of $1,240,000. It’s a “pro-family, pro-life, pro-growth” PAC: https://www.cwfpac.com/

Use the scoll-bar further down to see the right side of the data.

MariaDB [contributions]> select `Filer Name`, Office, BallotNumber, ForOrAgainst,`Contributor name`, Amount from contrib where Amount >= 100000 and `Receipt date` >= '2017-01-01' order by Amount DESC;
+------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------+--------------+--------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------+
| Filer Name                                                             | Office            | BallotNumber | ForOrAgainst | Contributor name                                                          | Amount     |
+------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------+--------------+--------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------+
| STAND FOR CHILDREN WA PAC                                              |                   |              |              | STAND FOR CHILDREN, INC.                                                  | 1000000.00 |
| PEOPLE FOR JENNY DURKAN                                                |                   |              |              | CIVIC ALLIANCE FOR A SOUND ECONOMY (SPONORED BY THE SEATTLE CHAMBER)      |  475000.00 |
| WA ST REPUB PARTY EXEMPT                                               |                   |              |              | REPUBLICAN STATE LEADERSHIP CO                                            |  400000.00 |
| EASTSIDE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                            |                   |              |              | NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                         |  350000.00 |
| ORANGE DONALD J                                                        | PORT COMMISSIONER |              |              | WASHINGTON CONSERVATION VOTERS ACTION FUND                                |  290000.00 |
| THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                 |                   |              |              | REPUBLICAN STATE LEADERSHIP CO                                            |  250000.00 |
| CIVIC ALLIANCE FOR A SOUND ECONOMY SPONSORED BY THE SEATTLE CHAMBER    |                   |              |              | AMAZON.COM                                                                |  250000.00 |
| CIT FOR PROGRESS ENTERPRISE WA                                         |                   |              |              | PHILLIPS 66                                                               |  250000.00 |
| REPUB ST LEADERSHIP COMM WA PAC                                        |                   |              |              | REPUBLICAN STATE LEADERSHIP COMMITTEE                                     |  250000.00 |
| WA CONSERVATION VOTERS ACTION FUND                                     |                   |              |              | LEAGUE OF CONSERVATION VOTERS                                             |  250000.00 |
| CIT FOR PROGRESS ENTERPRISE WA                                         |                   |              |              | ENTERPRISE WASHINGTON'S JOBS PAC                                          |  235000.00 |
| EASTSIDE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                            |                   |              |              | KENNEDY FUND                                                              |  225000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                   |              |              | DEMOCRATIC LEGISLATIVE CAMPAIGN COMMITTEE                                 |  200000.00 |
| SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTL UNION 775 QUALITY CARE COMM                     |                   |              |              | SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL UNION POLITICAL EDUCATION AND ACTION FUND |  200000.00 |
| THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                 |                   |              |              | REPUBLICAN STATE LEADERSHIP CO                                            |  200000.00 |
| EASTSIDE VALUES                                                        |                   |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE REPUBLICAN PARTY/EXEMPT ACCOUNT                          |  200000.00 |
| WORKING FAMILIES                                                       |                   |              |              | THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                    |  200000.00 |
| WORKING FAMILIES                                                       |                   |              |              | THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                    |  200000.00 |
| EASTSIDE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                            |                   |              |              | NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                         |  200000.00 |
| EASTSIDE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                            |                   |              |              | NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                         |  200000.00 |
| EASTSIDE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                            |                   |              |              | KENNEDY FUND                                                              |  170000.00 |
| MASTER BUILDERS ASSN OF KING & SNOHOMISH CO AFFORDABLE HOUSING COUNCIL |                   |              |              | MASTER BUILDERS ASSOCIATION OF KING & SNO COUNTIES                        |  150000.00 |
| GREENE KRIS L                                                          | PORT COMMISSIONER |              |              | VANCOUVER ENERGY                                                          |  150000.00 |
| GREENE KRIS L                                                          | PORT COMMISSIONER |              |              | TESORO SAVAGE PETROLEUM TERMINAL LLC                                      |  140000.00 |
| MASTER BUILDERS ASSN OF KING & SNOHOMISH CO AFFORDABLE HOUSING COUNCIL |                   |              |              | MASTER BUILDERS ASSOCIATION OF KING & SNO COUNTIES                        |  131238.00 |
| CIT FOR PROGRESS ENTERPRISE WA                                         |                   |              |              | ENTERPRISE WASHINGTON'S JOBS PAC                                          |  130000.00 |
| WORKING FAMILIES                                                       |                   |              |              | THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                    |  125000.00 |
| WA CONSERVATION VOTERS ACTION FUND                                     |                   |              |              | STEYER TOM                                                                |  125000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                   |              |              | STEYER THOMAS                                                             |  125000.00 |
| EASTSIDE VALUES                                                        |                   |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE REPUBLICAN PARTY/EXEMPT ACCOUNT                          |  125000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                   |              |              | BLOOMBERG MICHAEL R                                                       |  125000.00 |
| CAMPAIGN FOR TRIBAL SELF RELIANCE BY WA INDIAN GAMING ASSN             |                   |              |              | WASHINGTON INDIAN GAMING ASSOCIATION                                      |  125000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                   |              |              | BLOOMBERG MICHAEL R                                                       |  125000.00 |
| URQUHART JOHN W                                                        | COUNTY SHERIFF    |              |              | URQUHART JOHN W                                                           |  125000.00 |
| GREENE KRIS L                                                          | PORT COMMISSIONER |              |              | ENTERPRISE WA JOBS PAC                                                    |  122314.40 |
| COALITION FOR HEALTHY KIDS & EDUCATION                                 |                   |              | For          | BLOOMBERG MICHAEL R                                                       |  115000.00 |
| WORKING FAMILIES                                                       |                   |              |              | THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                    |  115000.00 |
| CAMPAIGN TO PREVENT FRAUD AND PROTECT SENIORS                          |                   | 1501         | For          | SEIU 775                                                                  |  110000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                   |              |              | WASHINGTON FEDERATION OF STATE EMPLOYEES                                  |  110000.00 |
| URQUHART JOHN W                                                        | COUNTY SHERIFF    |              |              | URQUHART JOHN                                                             |  103000.00 |
| REDUCE SEATTLE HOMELESSNESS NOW                                        |                   | 126          | For          | HANAUER NICK                                                              |  100000.00 |
| SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTL UNION 1199 NORTHWEST PAC                        |                   |              |              | SEIU HEALTHCARE 1199 NW                                                   |  100000.00 |
| CIT FOR PROGRESS ENTERPRISE WA                                         |                   |              |              | ENTERPRISE WASHINGTON'S JOBS PAC                                          |  100000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                   |              |              | WASHINGTON FEDERATION OF STATE EMPLOYEES                                  |  100000.00 |
| WORKING FAMILIES                                                       |                   |              |              | THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                    |  100000.00 |
| CIT FOR PROGRESS ENTERPRISE WA                                         |                   |              |              | PHILLLIPS 66                                                              |  100000.00 |
| ENTERPRISE WA JOBSPAC                                                  |                   |              |              | CHEVERON POLICY GOVT & PUBLIC AFFAIRS                                     |  100000.00 |
| WORKING FAMILIES                                                       |                   |              |              | THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                    |  100000.00 |
| SENATE REPUB CAMP COMM                                                 |                   |              |              | JOHN BRAUN FOR STATE SENATE                                               |  100000.00 |
| ENTERPRISE WA JOBSPAC                                                  |                   |              |              | TESORO COMPANIES                                                          |  100000.00 |
| WORKING FAMILIES                                                       |                   |              |              | THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                    |  100000.00 |
| ENTERPRISE WA JOBSPAC                                                  |                   |              |              | BNSF RAILWAY COMPANY                                                      |  100000.00 |
| CIVIC ALLIANCE FOR A SOUND ECONOMY SPONSORED BY THE SEATTLE CHAMBER    |                   |              |              | AMAZON.COM                                                                |  100000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                   |              |              | WASHINGTON CONSERVATION VOTERS                                            |  100000.00 |
| YES FOR VETS AND HUMAN SERVICES                                        |                   | 1            | For          | HANAUER NICOLAS                                                           |  100000.00 |
| WA ST REPUB PARTY EXEMPT                                               |                   |              |              | REPUBLICAN STATE LEADERSHIP CO                                            |  100000.00 |
| DE-ESCALATE WA I-940                                                   |                   | 940          | For          | PUYALLUP TRIBE OF INDIANS                                                 |  100000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                   |              |              | WASHINGTON CONSERVATION VOTERS ACTION FUND                                |  100000.00 |
| ENTERPRISE WA JOBSPAC                                                  |                   |              |              | TESORO COMPANIES                                                          |  100000.00 |
| KENNEDY FUND                                                           |                   |              |              | LABORERS POLITICAL LEAGUE EDUCATION FUND                                  |  100000.00 |
| EASTSIDE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                            |                   |              |              | NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                         |  100000.00 |
| EASTSIDE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                            |                   |              |              | NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                         |  100000.00 |
| WA CONSERVATION VOTERS ACTION FUND                                     |                   |              |              | BIG ORGANIZING ACTION FUND                                                |  100000.00 |
| WORKING FAMILIES                                                       |                   |              |              | THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                    |  100000.00 |
| WORKING FAMILIES                                                       |                   |              |              | THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                    |  100000.00 |
| WORKING FAMILIES                                                       |                   |              |              | THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                    |  100000.00 |
| EASTSIDE VALUES                                                        |                   |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE REPUBLICAN PARTY/EXEMPT ACCOUNT                          |  100000.00 |
| JENSEN JAMES E                                                         | PORT COMMISSIONER |              |              | JENSEN JAMES E                                                            |  100000.00 |
+------------------------------------------------------------------------+-------------------+--------------+--------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------+------------+
68 rows in set (0.84 sec)

MariaDB [contributions]> select sum(Amount) from contrib where Amount >= 100000 and `Receipt date` >= '2017-01-01' and `Filer name`='Eastside Leadership Council';
+-------------+
| sum(Amount) |
+-------------+
|  1345000.00 |
+-------------+
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

MariaDB [contributions]> select sum(Amount) from contrib where Amount >= 100000 and `Receipt date` >= '2017-01-01' and `Filer name`='Working Families';
+-------------+
| sum(Amount) |
+-------------+
|  1240000.00 |
+-------------+
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

2016

MariaDB [contributions]> select `Filer Name`, Office, BallotNumber, ForOrAgainst,`Contributor name`, Amount from contrib where Amount >= 100000 and `Receipt date` >= '2016-01-01' and `Receipt date` < '2017-01-01' order by Amount DESC;
+------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------+--------------+--------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------+-----------+
| Filer Name                                                             | Office                    | BallotNumber | ForOrAgainst | Contributor name                                                          | Amount    |
+------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------+--------------+--------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------+-----------+
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                           |              |              | HARRY TRUMAN FUND                                                         | 750000.00 |
| CAMPAIGN TO PREVENT FRAUD AND PROTECT SENIORS                          |                           | 1501         | For          | SEIU 775                                                                  | 700000.00 |
| WA ST DEMO CENT COMM NON EXEMPT                                        |                           |              |              | HOUSE DEMOCRATIC CAUCUS CAMPAIGN COMM.                                    | 600000.00 |
| ALLIANCE FOR GUN RESPONSIBILITY ERP COMM                               |                           | 1491         | For          | EVERYTOWN FOR GUN SAFETY ACTION FUND                                      | 500000.00 |
| ALLIANCE FOR GUN RESPONSIBILITY ERP COMM                               |                           | 1491         | For          | BALLMER STEVEN                                                            | 500000.00 |
| STAND FOR CHILDREN WA PAC                                              |                           |              |              | BALLMER CONNIE                                                            | 500000.00 |
| RAISE UP WA                                                            |                           | 1433         | For          | HANAUER NICOLAS                                                           | 500000.00 |
| WA EDUCATION ASSN PAC                                                  |                           |              |              | MISCELLANEOUS RECEIPTS                                                    | 500000.00 |
| ACCESS FOR ALL                                                         |                           | 1            | For          | CULTURAL ACCESS WASHINGTON                                                | 489332.00 |
| WA ST DEMO CENT COMM NON EXEMPT                                        |                           |              |              | WASHINGTON SENATE DEMOCRATIC CAMPAIGN                                     | 433000.00 |
| A SAFER SNOHOMISH CO                                                   |                           | 1            | For          | STILLAGUAMISH TRIBE OF INDIANS                                            | 400000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                           |              |              | HARRY TRUMAN FUND                                                         | 400000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                           |              |              | KENNEDY FUND                                                              | 400000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | SOROS JONATHAN                                                            | 400000.00 |
| COMMUNITY PROGRESS                                                     |                           |              |              | THE REAGAN FUND                                                           | 400000.00 |
| WA ST REPUB PARTY NON EXEMPT                                           |                           |              |              | SENATE REPUBLICAN CAMPAIGN COM                                            | 375000.00 |
| WA ST REPUB PARTY NON EXEMPT                                           |                           |              |              | HOUSE REPUBLICAN ORGANIZATIONA                                            | 375000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | REPRESENT US                                                              | 360000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                           |              |              | OUR WASHINGTON                                                            | 360000.00 |
| WA ST ASSN FOR JUSTICE JUSTICE FOR ALL                                 |                           |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE ASSOCIATION FOR JUSTICE JUSTICE IN ACTION                | 358150.66 |
| CAMPAIGN TO PREVENT FRAUD AND PROTECT SENIORS                          |                           | 1501         | For          | SEIU 775                                                                  | 350000.00 |
| GOOD GOVT LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                           |                           |              |              | THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                    | 350000.00 |
| INSLEE JAY R                                                           | GOVERNOR                  |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE DEMOCRATIC CENTRAL COMMITTEE                             | 300000.00 |
| SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTL UNION 1199 NORTHWEST PAC                        |                           |              |              | SEIU HEALTHCARE 1199 NW                                                   | 300000.00 |
| CIT FOR WORKING COURTS ENTERPRISE WA                                   |                           |              |              | VULCAN INC.                                                               | 300000.00 |
| NO ON 732 SPONSORED BY THE ASSN OF WA BUSINESS                         |                           | 732          | Against      | KAISER ALUMINUM                                                           | 300000.00 |
| SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTL UNION 775 QUALITY CARE COMM                     |                           |              |              | SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL UNION POLITICAL EDUCATION AND ACTION FUND | 300000.00 |
| SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTL UNION WA ST COUNCIL PAC                         |                           |              |              | SEIU WASHINGTON STATE COUNCIL                                             | 300000.00 |
| COMMUNITY PROGRESS                                                     |                           |              |              | THE REAGAN FUND                                                           | 300000.00 |
| INSLEE JAY R                                                           | GOVERNOR                  |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE DEMOCRATIC CENTRAL COMMITTEE                             | 290000.00 |
| ALLIANCE FOR GUN RESPONSIBILITY ERP COMM                               |                           | 1491         | For          | ALLEN PAUL G                                                              | 250000.00 |
| SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTL UNION WA ST COUNCIL PAC                         |                           |              |              | SEIU WASHINGTON STATE COUNCIL                                             | 250000.00 |
| OUR WASHINGTON                                                         |                           |              |              | DEMOCRATIC GOVERNORS ASSN                                                 | 250000.00 |
| ALLIANCE FOR GUN RESPONSIBILITY ERP COMM                               |                           | 1491         | For          | HANAUER NICOLAS                                                           | 250000.00 |
| ALLIANCE FOR GUN RESPONSIBILITY ERP COMM                               |                           | 1491         | For          | HANAUER NICOLAS                                                           | 250000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | BALLMER CONNIE                                                            | 250000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                           |              |              | KENNEDY FUND                                                              | 250000.00 |
| JUDICIAL INTEGRITY WA PAC                                              |                           |              |              | FISHER KEN                                                                | 250000.00 |
| MAINSTREAM VOTERS OF WA                                                |                           |              |              | HARRY TRUMAN FUND                                                         | 250000.00 |
| NO ON 732 SPONSORED BY THE ASSN OF WA BUSINESS                         |                           | 732          | Against      | AMERICAN FUEL & PETROCHEMICAL MANUFACTURERS                               | 250000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | BALLMER CONNIE                                                            | 250000.00 |
| WA ST DEMO CENT COMM NON EXEMPT                                        |                           |              |              | ORR JAMES L                                                               | 250000.00 |
| RAISE UP WA                                                            |                           | 1433         | For          | SEIU WASHINGTON STATE COUNCIL                                             | 250000.00 |
| OUR WASHINGTON                                                         |                           |              |              | SEIU WA STATE COUNCIL PAC                                                 | 250000.00 |
| WA CONSERVATION VOTERS ACTION FUND                                     |                           |              |              | LEAGUE OF CONSERVATION VOTERS                                             | 250000.00 |
| SOUTH SOUND FUTURE PAC ENTERPRISE WA                                   |                           |              |              | ENTERPRISE WASHINGTON'S JOBSPAC                                           | 250000.00 |
| WA ST DEMO CENT COMM NON EXEMPT                                        |                           |              |              | BLOOMBERG MICHAEL                                                         | 248000.00 |
| INSLEE JAY R                                                           | GOVERNOR                  |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE DEMOCRATIC CENTRAL COMMITTEE                             | 239440.00 |
| AUDUBON WA                                                             |                           | 732          | For          | AUDUBON SOCIETY DBA AUDUBON WASHINGTON                                    | 234000.00 |
| WORKING FAMILIES                                                       |                           |              |              | THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                    | 225000.00 |
| SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTL UNION WA ST COUNCIL PAC                         |                           |              |              | SEIU WASHINGTON STATE COUNCIL                                             | 210000.00 |
| SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTL UNION WA ST COUNCIL PAC                         |                           |              |              | SEIU WASHINGTON STATE COUNCIL                                             | 210000.00 |
| SENATE REPUB CAMP COMM                                                 |                           |              |              | SENATE COMMITTEE FOR MARK SCHO                                            | 205000.00 |
| FAIRNESS PROJECT                                                       |                           |              |              | THE FAIRNESS PROJECT                                                      | 200247.00 |
| CAMPAIGN TO PREVENT FRAUD AND PROTECT SENIORS                          |                           | 1501         | For          | SEIU 775                                                                  | 200000.00 |
| WA ST DEMO CENT COMM EXEMPT                                            |                           |              |              | DEMOCRATIC GOVERNORS ASSOCIATION                                          | 200000.00 |
| STAND FOR CHILDREN WA PAC                                              |                           |              |              | HASTINGS REED                                                             | 200000.00 |
| OURVOTESCOUNT                                                          |                           |              |              | SEIU WASHINGTON STATE COUNCIL                                             | 200000.00 |
| ALLIANCE FOR GUN RESPONSIBILITY ERP COMM                               |                           | 1491         | For          | AMERICANS FOR RESPONSIBLE SOLUTIONS PAC                                   | 200000.00 |
| GOOD GOVT LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                           |                           |              |              | THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                    | 200000.00 |
| GOOD GOVT LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                           |                           |              |              | THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                    | 200000.00 |
| CIT FOR WORKING COURTS ENTERPRISE WA                                   |                           |              |              | GATES BILL                                                                | 200000.00 |
| RAISE UP WA                                                            |                           | 1433         | For          | HANAUER NICOLAS                                                           | 200000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | REPRESENT US                                                              | 200000.00 |
| CAMPAIGN TO PREVENT FRAUD AND PROTECT SENIORS                          |                           | 1501         | For          | SEIU LOCAL 925                                                            | 200000.00 |
| WORKING FAMILIES                                                       |                           |              |              | THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                    | 200000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | REPRESENT US                                                              | 200000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                           |              |              | HARRY TRUMAN FUND                                                         | 190000.00 |
| BRYANT WILLIAM L                                                       | GOVERNOR                  |              |              | KING COUNTY REPUBLICAN PARTY                                              | 185000.00 |
| WA REALTORS PAC                                                        |                           |              |              | NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS                                          | 181830.35 |
| BRYANT WILLIAM L                                                       | GOVERNOR                  |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE REPUBLICAN PARTY                                         | 175000.00 |
| KNOW YOUR JUDICIAL BALLOT PAC                                          |                           |              |              | WEA PAC                                                                   | 175000.00 |
| SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTL UNION LOCAL 925 PUBLIC SERVICE PAC              |                           |              |              | MISCELLANEOUS RECEIPTS                                                    | 174346.00 |
| INSLEE JAY R                                                           | GOVERNOR                  |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE DEMOCRATIC CENTRAL COMMITTEE                             | 172000.00 |
| BRYANT WILLIAM L                                                       | GOVERNOR                  |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE REPUBLICAN PARTY                                         | 170000.00 |
| INSLEE JAY R                                                           | GOVERNOR                  |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE DEMOCRATIC CENTRAL COMMITTEE                             | 170000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                           |              |              | SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL UNION                                     | 162000.00 |
| CAMPAIGN FOR TRIBAL SELF RELIANCE BY WA INDIAN GAMING ASSN             |                           |              |              | WASHINGTON INDIAN GAMING ASSOCIATION                                      | 160000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | EVERY VOICE                                                               | 155000.00 |
| STAND FOR CHILDREN WA PAC                                              |                           |              |              | WA CHARTERS ACTION PAC                                                    | 153200.00 |
| WA ST REPUB PARTY NON EXEMPT                                           |                           |              |              | FISHER KENNETH L                                                          | 150000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | EVERY VOICE                                                               | 150000.00 |
| ALLIANCE FOR GUN RESPONSIBILITY ERP COMM                               |                           | 1491         | For          | HANAUER NICOLAS                                                           | 150000.00 |
| MASS TRANSIT NOW                                                       |                           | 1            | For          | MICROSOFT                                                                 | 150000.00 |
| HOUSE REPUB ORG COMM                                                   |                           |              |              | FRIENDS OF DAN KRISTIANSEN - S                                            | 150000.00 |
| RAISE UP WA                                                            |                           | 1433         | For          | HANAUER NICOLAS                                                           | 150000.00 |
| MAINSTREAM VOTERS OF WA                                                |                           |              |              | KENNEDY FUND                                                              | 150000.00 |
| THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                 |                           |              |              | REPUBLICAN STATE LEADERSHIP CO                                            | 150000.00 |
| HARRY TRUMAN FUND                                                      |                           |              |              | WA EDUCATION ASSN PAC / WEA PAC                                           | 150000.00 |
| WA REALTORS PAC                                                        |                           |              |              | NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS                                          | 150000.00 |
| NO SOUND TRANSIT 3                                                     |                           | 1            | Against      | FAMILIES FOR SUSTAINABLE TRANSIT                                          | 150000.00 |
| MASTER BUILDERS ASSN OF KING & SNOHOMISH CO AFFORDABLE HOUSING COUNCIL |                           |              |              | MASTER BUILDERS ASSOCIATION OF KING & SNO COUNTIES                        | 150000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | EVERY VOICE                                                               | 150000.00 |
| CAMPAIGN TO PREVENT FRAUD AND PROTECT SENIORS                          |                           | 1501         | For          | SEIU 775                                                                  | 150000.00 |
| WA ST DEMO CENT COMM EXEMPT                                            |                           |              |              | LABORERS' POLITICAL LEAGUE                                                | 150000.00 |
| KEEP WA ROLLING                                                        |                           |              |              | MICROSOFT                                                                 | 150000.00 |
| RAISE UP WA                                                            |                           | 1433         | For          | THE FAIRNESS PROJECT                                                      | 150000.00 |
| RAISE UP WA                                                            |                           | 1433         | For          | UFCW LOCAL 21                                                             | 150000.00 |
| HARRY TRUMAN FUND                                                      |                           |              |              | WA EDUCATION ASSN PAC / WEA PAC                                           | 150000.00 |
| WORKING FAMILIES                                                       |                           |              |              | THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                    | 150000.00 |
| BRYANT WILLIAM L                                                       | GOVERNOR                  |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE REPUBLICAN PARTY                                         | 150000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                           |              |              | KENNEDY FUND                                                              | 150000.00 |
| MCLAUGHLIN STEVEN A                                                    | PUBLIC LANDS COMMISSIONER |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE REPUBLICAN PARTY                                         | 150000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | ELDRIDGE SEAN                                                             | 150000.00 |
| WA ST DEMO CENT COMM NON EXEMPT                                        |                           |              |              | STEYER THOMAS F                                                           | 150000.00 |
| SENATE REPUB CAMP COMM                                                 |                           |              |              | COMMITTEE FOR MARK SCHOESLER S                                            | 145000.00 |
| FUSE VOTES                                                             |                           |              |              | FUSE WASHINGTON                                                           | 145000.00 |
| INSLEE JAY R                                                           | GOVERNOR                  |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE DEMOCRATIC CENTRAL COMMITTEE                             | 140000.00 |
| ALLIANCE FOR GUN RESPONSIBILITY ERP COMM                               |                           | 1491         | For          | HANAUER NICOLAS                                                           | 140000.00 |
| WA ST DEMO CENT COMM EXEMPT                                            |                           |              |              | WASHINGTON FEDERATION OF STATE EMPLOYEES  (WFSE)                          | 140000.00 |
| SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTL UNION LOCAL 925 PUBLIC SERVICE PAC              |                           |              |              | SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL UNION                                     | 136762.25 |
| SOUTHWEST COMMUNITIES ENTERPRISE WA                                    |                           |              |              | ENTERPRISE WASHINGTON'S JOBSPAC                                           | 134000.00 |
| CULTURAL ACCESS WASHINGTON                                             |                           |              |              | SEATTLE THEATRE GROUP                                                     | 133732.00 |
| LEGISLATIVE MAJORITY PAC - SPONSOR DEMO LEG CAMP COMM                  |                           |              |              | DEMOCRATIC LEGISLATIVE CAMPAIGN COMMITTEE                                 | 130000.00 |
| MCLAUGHLIN STEVEN A                                                    | PUBLIC LANDS COMMISSIONER |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE REPUBLICAN PARTY                                         | 130000.00 |
| SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTL UNION 775 QUALITY CARE COMM                     |                           |              |              | SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL UNION POLITICAL EDUCATION AND ACTION FUND | 129168.67 |
| WA CHARTERS ACTION PAC                                                 |                           |              |              | BALLMER CONNIE                                                            | 125000.00 |
| WA CHARTERS ACTION PAC                                                 |                           |              |              | BALLMER STEVE                                                             | 125000.00 |
| SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTL UNION 1199 NORTHWEST PAC                        |                           |              |              | SEIU HEALTHCARE 1199 NW                                                   | 125000.00 |
| WA CONSERVATION VOTERS ACTION FUND                                     |                           |              |              | OREGON GIVING BACK FUND                                                   | 125000.00 |
| SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTL UNION WA ST COUNCIL PAC                         |                           |              |              | SEIU WASHINGTON STATE COUNCIL                                             | 125000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                           |              |              | HARRY TRUMAN FUND                                                         | 125000.00 |
| WA ST REPUB PARTY NON EXEMPT                                           |                           |              |              | DEDOMENICO MARK DR.                                                       | 125000.00 |
| THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                 |                           |              |              | REPUBLICAN STATE LEADERSHIP CO                                            | 125000.00 |
| WA ST DEMO CENT COMM EXEMPT                                            |                           |              |              | SEIU WA STATE COUNCIL                                                     | 120000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                           |              |              | KENNEDY FUND                                                              | 120000.00 |
| SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTL UNION WA ST COUNCIL PAC                         |                           |              |              | SEIU WASHINGTON STATE COUNCIL                                             | 120000.00 |
| SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTL UNION WA ST COUNCIL PAC                         |                           |              |              | SEIU WASHINGTON STATE COUNCIL                                             | 120000.00 |
| INSLEE JAY R                                                           | GOVERNOR                  |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE DEMOCRATIC CENTRAL COMMITTEE                             | 119720.00 |
| HARRY TRUMAN FUND                                                      |                           |              |              | SEIU WA STATE COUNCIL                                                     | 117500.00 |
| HARRY TRUMAN FUND                                                      |                           |              |              | SEIU WA STATE COUNCIL                                                     | 117500.00 |
| KNOW YOUR JUDICIAL BALLOT PAC                                          |                           |              |              | JUSTICE FOR ALL PAC                                                       | 115000.00 |
| WA ST REPUB PARTY NON EXEMPT                                           |                           |              |              | DEDOMENICO MARK DR.                                                       | 115000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                           |              |              | SEIU WASHINGTON STATE COUNCIL PAC                                         | 115000.00 |
| DENTISTS FOR PATIENT CARE (WA ST DENTAL PAC)                           |                           |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE DENTAL PAC                                               | 112000.00 |
| REAGAN FUND                                                            |                           |              |              | HOLLAND CLYDE                                                             | 110500.00 |
| RAISE UP WA                                                            |                           | 1433         | For          | HANAUER NICOLAS                                                           | 110000.00 |
| REAGAN FUND                                                            |                           |              |              | FISHER KENNETH                                                            | 103375.00 |
| YES ON I-125 COMM                                                      |                           | 125          | For          | SEIU 775 HEALTHCARE NW                                                    | 100000.00 |
| SENATE REPUB CAMP COMM                                                 |                           |              |              | ANN RIVERS FOR STATE SENATE                                               | 100000.00 |
| REAGAN FUND                                                            |                           |              |              | REPUBLICAN STATE LEADERSHIP CO                                            | 100000.00 |
| COMMUNITY PROGRESS                                                     |                           |              |              | THE REAGAN FUND                                                           | 100000.00 |
| BRYANT WILLIAM L                                                       | GOVERNOR                  |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE REPUBLICAN PARTY                                         | 100000.00 |
| WA ST DEMO CENT COMM EXEMPT                                            |                           |              |              | WASHINGTON FEDERATION OF STATE EMPLOYEES  (WFSE)                          | 100000.00 |
| WA ST REPUB PARTY NON EXEMPT                                           |                           |              |              | HOLLAND CLYDE                                                             | 100000.00 |
| ENTERPRISE WA JOBSPAC                                                  |                           |              |              | CHEVERON POLICY GOVT & PUBLIC AFFAIRS                                     | 100000.00 |
| QUALITY COMMUNITIES COMM (REAGAN FUND)                                 |                           |              |              | THE REAGAN FUND                                                           | 100000.00 |
| WA ST REPUB PARTY NON EXEMPT                                           |                           |              |              | HOLLAND CLYDE                                                             | 100000.00 |
| FAMILIES FOR SUSTAINABLE TRANSIT                                       |                           | 1            | Against      | KEMPER HOLDINGS                                                           | 100000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | VON MUEFFLING WILLIAM                                                     | 100000.00 |
| INSLEE JAY R                                                           | GOVERNOR                  |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE DEMOCRATIC CENTRAL COMMITTEE                             | 100000.00 |
| WA ST DEMO CENT COMM EXEMPT                                            |                           |              |              | PUYALLUP TRIBE OF INDIANS                                                 | 100000.00 |
| WORKING FAMILIES                                                       |                           |              |              | THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                    | 100000.00 |
| JUDICIAL INTEGRITY WA PAC                                              |                           |              |              | FISHER KEN                                                                | 100000.00 |
| HARRY TRUMAN FUND                                                      |                           |              |              | SEIU 775 QUALITY CARE COMMITTEE                                           | 100000.00 |
| MASS TRANSIT NOW                                                       |                           | 1            | For          | AMAZON                                                                    | 100000.00 |
| SENATE REPUB CAMP COMM                                                 |                           |              |              | JOHN BRAUN FOR STATE SENATE                                               | 100000.00 |
| HOUSE DEMO CAMP COMM                                                   |                           |              |              | FRIENDS OF FRANK CHOPP SURPLUS ACCOUNT                                    | 100000.00 |
| MASS TRANSIT NOW                                                       |                           | 1            | For          | MICROSOFT                                                                 | 100000.00 |
| SENATE REPUB CAMP COMM                                                 |                           |              |              | CURTIS KING FOR STATE SENATOR                                             | 100000.00 |
| WA CHARTERS ACTION PAC                                                 |                           |              |              | BINDER KATHERINE                                                          | 100000.00 |
| HARRY TRUMAN FUND                                                      |                           |              |              | SEIU 1199 NW                                                              | 100000.00 |
| RAISE UP WA                                                            |                           | 1433         | For          | THE FAIRNESS PROJECT                                                      | 100000.00 |
| THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                 |                           |              |              | REPUBLICAN STATE LEADERSHIP CO                                            | 100000.00 |
| SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTL UNION 775 QUALITY CARE COMM                     |                           |              |              | SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL UNION POLITICAL EDUCATION AND ACTION FUND | 100000.00 |
| OUR WASHINGTON                                                         |                           |              |              | SEIU WA STATE COUNCIL PAC                                                 | 100000.00 |
| MAINSTREAM VOTERS OF WA                                                |                           |              |              | HARRY TRUMAN FUND                                                         | 100000.00 |
| OUR WASHINGTON                                                         |                           |              |              | WA FEDERATION OF STATE EMPLOYEES                                          | 100000.00 |
| WA ST REPUB PARTY NON EXEMPT                                           |                           |              |              | FISHER KENNETH L                                                          | 100000.00 |
| HARRY TRUMAN FUND                                                      |                           |              |              | DEMOCRATIC LEGISLATIVE CAMPAIGN COMMITTEE                                 | 100000.00 |
| HARRY TRUMAN FUND                                                      |                           |              |              | SEIU HEALTHCARE UNITED FOR QUALITY CARE 1199 NW                           | 100000.00 |
| SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTL UNION 1199 NORTHWEST PAC                        |                           |              |              | SEIU HEALTHCARE 1199 NW                                                   | 100000.00 |
| COMMUNITY PROGRESS                                                     |                           |              |              | THE REAGAN FUND                                                           | 100000.00 |
| THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                 |                           |              |              | REPUBLICAN STATE LEADERSHIP CO                                            | 100000.00 |
| FAMILIES FOR SUSTAINABLE TRANSIT                                       |                           | 1            | Against      | KEMPER HOLDINGS                                                           | 100000.00 |
| WA ST DENTAL PAC                                                       |                           |              |              | WASHINGTON STATE DENTAL ASSOCIATION                                       | 100000.00 |
| QUALITY COMMUNITIES COMM (REAGAN FUND)                                 |                           |              |              | THE REAGAN FUND                                                           | 100000.00 |
| RAISE UP WA                                                            |                           | 1433         | For          | WASHINGTON EDUCATION ASSOCIATION                                          | 100000.00 |
| MAINSTREAM VOTERS OF WA                                                |                           |              |              | KENNEDY FUND                                                              | 100000.00 |
| CIT FOR PROGRESS ENTERPRISE WA                                         |                           |              |              | ENTERPRISE WASHINGTON'S JOBSPAC                                           | 100000.00 |
| FAIRNESS PROJECT                                                       |                           |              |              | THE FAIRNESS PROJECT                                                      | 100000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | SOROS JONATHAN                                                            | 100000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | DEVAAN JON                                                                | 100000.00 |
| CARBON WA                                                              |                           | 732          | For          | KELLY PETER                                                               | 100000.00 |
| NO ON 732 SPONSORED BY THE ASSN OF WA BUSINESS                         |                           | 732          | Against      | PUGET SOUND ENERGY                                                        | 100000.00 |
| REAGAN FUND                                                            |                           |              |              | REPUBLICAN STATE LEADERSHIP CO                                            | 100000.00 |
| AUDUBON WA                                                             |                           | 732          | For          | THE DURST ORGANIZATION LP                                                 | 100000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | REPRESENT US                                                              | 100000.00 |
| CAMPAIGN TO PREVENT FRAUD AND PROTECT SENIORS                          |                           | 1501         | For          | SEIU 775                                                                  | 100000.00 |
| HARRY TRUMAN FUND                                                      |                           |              |              | WA EDUCATION ASSN PAC                                                     | 100000.00 |
| SEATTLE PROTECTS WOMEN UNITE HERE LOCAL 8 FOR YES ON 124               |                           | 124          | For          | UNITE HERE LOCAL 8                                                        | 100000.00 |
| WA ST DEMO CENT COMM EXEMPT                                            |                           |              |              | DEMOCRATIC GOVERNORS ASSOCIATION                                          | 100000.00 |
| WA ST DEMO CENT COMM EXEMPT                                            |                           |              |              | WASHINGTON EDUCATION ASSOCIATION PAC                                      | 100000.00 |
| THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                 |                           |              |              | STRAT PAC                                                                 | 100000.00 |
| MASS TRANSIT NOW                                                       |                           | 1            | For          | VULCAN, INC.                                                              | 100000.00 |
| MASS TRANSIT NOW                                                       |                           | 1            | For          | EXPEDIA                                                                   | 100000.00 |
| MASS TRANSIT NOW                                                       |                           | 1            | For          | WASHINGTON ENGINEERS PAC                                                  | 100000.00 |
| KENNEDY FUND                                                           |                           |              |              | SEIU LOCAL 775                                                            | 100000.00 |
| FAIRNESS PROJECT                                                       |                           |              |              | THE FAIRNESS PROJECT                                                      | 100000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | ELDRIDGE SEAN                                                             | 100000.00 |
| WA ST REPUB PARTY NON EXEMPT                                           |                           |              |              | HOLLAND CLYDE                                                             | 100000.00 |
| SOUTHWEST COMMUNITIES ENTERPRISE WA                                    |                           |              |              | ENTERPRISE WASHINGTON'S JOBSPAC                                           | 100000.00 |
| GOOD GOVT LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                           |                           |              |              | THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                    | 100000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                           |              |              | WASHINGTON FEDERATION OF STATE EMPLOYEES                                  | 100000.00 |
| OUR WASHINGTON                                                         |                           |              |              | WA FEDERATION OF STATE EMPLOYEES                                          | 100000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | ELDRIDGE SEAN                                                             | 100000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | ABRAMS JEREMY JJ                                                          | 100000.00 |
| WORKING FAMILIES                                                       |                           |              |              | THE LEADERSHIP COUNCIL                                                    | 100000.00 |
| RAISE UP WA                                                            |                           | 1433         | For          | SEIU HEALTHCARE 1199NW                                                    | 100000.00 |
| SEATTLE PROTECTS WOMEN UNITE HERE LOCAL 8 FOR YES ON 124               |                           | 124          | For          | UNITE HERE                                                                | 100000.00 |
| RAISE UP WA                                                            |                           | 1433         | For          | THE FAIRNESS PROJECT WA PAC                                               | 100000.00 |
| KENNEDY FUND                                                           |                           |              |              | SEIU HEALTHCARE 1199NW                                                    | 100000.00 |
| NEW DIRECTION PAC                                                      |                           |              |              | SEIU WASHINGTON STATE COUNCIL PAC                                         | 100000.00 |
| OUR WASHINGTON                                                         |                           |              |              | WA CONSERVATION VOTERS ACTION FUND                                        | 100000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | ELDRIDGE SEAN                                                             | 100000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | JOHNSON JOHN S  III                                                       | 100000.00 |
| WA ST DEMO CENT COMM EXEMPT                                            |                           |              |              | PUYALLUP TRIBE OF INDIANS                                                 | 100000.00 |
| MASS TRANSIT NOW                                                       |                           | 1            | For          | IBEW PAC VOLUNTARY FUND                                                   | 100000.00 |
| MASS TRANSIT NOW                                                       |                           | 1            | For          | GATES WILLIAM  III                                                        | 100000.00 |
| REAGAN FUND                                                            |                           |              |              | REPUBLICAN STATE LEADERSHIP CO                                            | 100000.00 |
| RAISE UP WA                                                            |                           | 1433         | For          | THE FAIRNESS PROJECT                                                      | 100000.00 |
| NO ON 732 SPONSORED BY THE ASSN OF WA BUSINESS                         |                           | 732          | Against      | KAISER ALUMINUM                                                           | 100000.00 |
| INTEGRITY WA                                                           |                           | 1464         | For          | WILSON FRED                                                               | 100000.00 |
+------------------------------------------------------------------------+---------------------------+--------------+--------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------+-----------+
223 rows in set (1.29 sec)

See Campaign money pours into Washington state races days before election.

Employers should stop subsidizing free parking by employees

The Bellevue Planning Commission has recently suggested encouraging employers to stop subsidizing free parking by employees.   The intention is to incentivize people to  use public transportation and other alternatives to commuting by car.   The benefits would be clear: less traffic congestion, less pollution, and a more pleasant environment.

As expected, there’s a posting on nextdoor.com calling on Bellevue residents to stop the proposed plan.  The posting encourages reader to email council members and to express their opposition to the increased parking fees.

One person said that the proposed fees would be an economic hardship on working families.

Yes, the policy to charge for parking will hit everyone, but employers have the option of paying higher salaries. Also, that argument (“It will hit working families”) can be used to oppose almost any regulation that protects people via an economic incentives. Safety regulations on cars, planes, food, and a myriad of goods result in higher prices, but those higher prices are needed to reflect the hidden costs and external costs (e.g., pollution) from the goods and services.  Countries worldwide are moving towards green economies less dependent on fossil fuels.  Our lives and communities need to be reconfigured to reflect the necessary trade-offs.

A similar proposal in 2015 was scrapped because of concerns that drivers would park at malls and would disrupt local businesses.

Since heavy traffic is detrimental to our health and quality of life, it is indeed desirable to make incentives for people to use public transportation and other alternatives to cars. Google “air pollution health” and you’ll find many scary scientific articles about how bad auto pollution is to the lungs of people living near freeways. Do you like sitting in traffic and breathing toxic exhaust? Are you OK with making nearby residents and workers breathe it?

Was the Noble Savage noble? Or savage?

There has been a debate in the press recently about whether the state (nation) is fundamentally a source of exploitation and war, or whether it’s a civilizing influence on humans’ natural brutal nature. The debate has echoes of Jean-Jacque Rousseau versus Thomas Hobbes, as well as echos of FDR versus the Koch brothers.

In short, was the Noble Savage noble or savage?

Anarchist and Yale political scientist James Scott has written a series of books critical of the state and nostalgic for the supposed peaceful and cooperative hunter-gatherer past. In a piece published in The Nation, political scientist and legal scholar Samuel Moyn reviews Scott’s work and concludes that Scott both ignores the brutality of pre-state humans and understates the benefits of states and civilization. The very qualities of equality and freedom that Scott bestows are a product of states.

Some other references suggesting that hunter-gatherers were relatively peaceful and egalitarian include:

Human Nature May Not Be So Warlike After All

Warfare was uncommon among hunter-gatherers: study

“Warfare was uncommon among hunter-gatherers, and killings among nomadic groups were often due to competition for women or interpersonal disputes, researchers in Finland said Thursday.” (Is it really war or just an interpersonal feud? Several researchers point out that organized war, with masses of troops probably required states, but feuds and minor killings sill occurred in hunter-gatherer society.)

But there are many scholars who think hunter-gatherers were war-like and treated woman poorly.

Hunter-gatherers were brutal and we have the state to thank for a decrease in violence and an increase in equality

Review of the book Violence and Warfare among Hunter-Gatherers, Journal of Anthropological Research. “LeBlanc develops a set of features common to hunter-gatherer warfare cross-culturally and argues that overwhelming ethnographic evidence shows intergroup violence was frequently dangerous but likely tied to resource stress between human populations.” “The reader finishes the book with an understanding that interpersonal violence and warfare occurred at all levels of sociopolitical complexity, predated colonization, and were widely variable in intensity and frequency.”

The Better Angels of Our Nature: Why Violence Has Declined is a 2011 book by Steven Pinker.

[Pinker] argues that violence in the world has declined both in the long run and in the short run and suggests explanations as to why this has occurred.The book contains a wealth of data simply documenting violence across time and geography. This paints a picture of massive declines in violence of all forms, from war, to improved treatment of children. He highlights the role of nation-state monopolies on force, of commerce (making “other people become more valuable alive than dead”), of increased literacy and communication (promoting empathy), as well as a rise in a rational problem-solving orientation as possible causes of this decline in violence. He notes that, paradoxically, our impression of violence has not tracked this decline, perhaps because of increased communication,[2] and that further decline is not inevitable, but is contingent on forces harnessing our better motivations such as empathy and increases in reason. (Source)

No, hunter gatherers were not peaceful paragons of gender equality Lots of graphs. Violence is decreasing over time.

10,000-year-old massacre suggests hunter-gatherers went to war

Prehistoric Massacre Hints at War Among Hunter-Gatherers

Finding a hunter-gatherer massacre scene that may change history of human warfare “We have discovered the oldest known case of violence between two groups of hunter gatherers took place there, with ten excavated skeletons showing evidence of having been killed with both sharp and blunt weapons.” “[M]any scholars have argued that warfare must have emerged after farming and more complex political systems arose.” But these findings challenge that view.

Noble or Savage? “The era of the hunter-gatherer was not the social and environmental Eden that some suggest.”
 

My concern with this is that many anarchists and bottom-up proponents on the Left are (perhaps unwittingly) aiding libertarians who want to destroy the New Deal and regulatory state crafted by progressive politics of the last 100 years. Yes, the state is often corrupted and used to harm people. Our task is to fix it so that it serves the many.

Dishonest, negative campaign ads by Republicans in Bellevue

I got a flier in the mail today from Friends of Jared Nieuwenhuis, Friends of Steve Fricke, and Friends of Phil Yin that says “STOP THESE CANDIDATES FROM BRINGING HEROIN INTO BELLEVUE.” The candidates referred to are Karol Brown, Lynne Robinson, and Janice Zahn.

What a scare tactic! If this isn’t negative campaigning, I don’t know what is.

Karol Brown has repeatedly said (including in comments on nextdoor.com, at a half dozen candidates forums, and on her website) that she opposes bringing safe injection sites into Bellevue. The City Council has effectively banned such sites from Bellevue for the foreseeable future. Besides, it’s a medical issue and shouldn’t be politicized!

The flier makes it appear that the candidates, or people who support such sites, want to bring heroin into Bellevue. Ridiculous and not true.

KAROL OPPOSES BRINGING SUCH SITES TO BELLEVUE and has repeatedly said that!

Lynne Robinson voted against safe injection sites when the issue came up for a vote on the city council.   Janice Zahn too said she opposes them, on nextdoor.com. The headline “WRONG ON HEROIN” is hitting below the belt. It gives the impression that these candidates want to bring heroin into Bellevue.

Image of back of campaign flier by Friends of Jared Nieuwenhuis, Steve Fricks, and Phil Yin

Such dishonest politicking (swiftboating, fake news) is customary at the national level. How unfortunate that we have it locally too.

Please don’t degrade local politics in a similar way. The three females have stated they oppose safe injection sites in Bellevue. The three male candidates are playing a transparently dirty trick. Besides, there is an epidemic, and addicts are dying. The people who propose safe-injection sites in King County are trying to save lives. They’re not trying to “bring heroin.” Heroin is already here. The City Council has voted against the sites for Bellevue. Please stop exploiting this issue for political purposes.

As further evidence of the politicization of the issue: “Chris Vance, a former state Republican Party chairman, said he believes those leading the I-27 campaign sincerely believe safe-injection is bad policy. But they also see it as a way to make political gains.” https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/politics/bellevue-bans-safe-injection-sites-for-heroin-users/

Image of back of campaign flier by Friends of Jared Nieuwenhuis, Steve Fricks, and Phil Yin

Opponents of safe injection sites passionately oppose/attack any politician who even refuses to agree to ban the sites in King County. And if the politician votes against the sites or announces their opposition, they are accused of lacking the courage of their convictions and of wanting to bring heroin into Bellevue. Heads you win, tails I lose. Meanwhile, people are dying and the homeless languish on the streets.

Wanting to leave open the possibility of safe injection sites in King County is very different from wanting to bring heroin to Bellevue, which is what the ads claimed. The fact is: people are shooting heroin every day — it’s a national crisis — and people are dying from overdoses every day. A safe injection site makes a lot of sense for the addicts who are still using. It’s not encouraging addiction, any more than condoms encourage unsafe sex. Abstinence programs do not work in either case.

Some more attack ads

This one is paid for by Friends of Steve Fricke:

And here’s an ad by the Master Builders:
Master Builders attack ad

Time to stop being polite to Repugs: Stop being Complicit

In society there are rules of etiquette that enjoin us to respect political and religious differences.  For example, at work, at the store, and on social networks such as nextdoor.com, we are expected to be nonpartisan and to respect differences of opinion.

But given the racism, sexism, craziness, and all-round destructiveness of the conservative movement — especially as realized by Donald Trump — it is our moral obligation to loudly oppose conservative thinking in all its forms.

Just as we are morally obligated to oppose fascism.

Shout down and insult conservatives in your midst!

As Senator Jeff Flake said in his speech announcing his retirement, “I will not be complicit.”

Kushner admitted: “Trump thinks Republicans are stupid”: “So basically Trump was deliberately and successfully lying about his belief that Obama’s birth certificate was somehow false since 2011.  He perpetuated this lie because it would appeal to Republicans — and it did — but he didn’t actually believe it himself.”

From The Atlantic:

In 2008, three-quarters of the major GOP presidential candidates said they believed in evolution, but in 2012 it was down to a third, and then in 2016, just one did. That one, Jeb Bush, was careful to say that evolutionary biology was only his truth, that “it does not need to be in the curriculum” of public schools, and that if it is, it could be accompanied by creationist teaching. A two-to-one majority of Republicans say they “support establishing Christianity as the national religion,” according to Public Policy Polling.

Before Trump won their nomination and the presidency, when he was still “a cancer on conservatism” that must be “discarded” (former Governor Rick Perry) and an “utterly amoral” “narcissist at a level I don’t think this country’s ever seen” (Senator Ted Cruz), Republicans hated Trump’s ideological incoherence—they didn’t yet understand that his campaign logic was a new kind, blending exciting tales with a showmanship that transcends ideology.

The fact-checking website PolitiFact looked at more than 400 of his statements as a candidate and as president and found that almost 50 percent were false and another 20 percent were mostly false.

Conservative commentator George F. Will: “It is urgent for Americans to think and speak clearly about President Trump’s inability to do either. This seems to be not a mere disinclination but a disability. It is not merely the result of intellectual sloth but of an untrained mind bereft of information and married to stratospheric self-confidence. ”

James Madison” “The day will come when our Republic will be an impossibility… because wealth will be concentrated in the hands of a few.”

Valerie Tarico: “Trump is appointing a fox to every henhouse based on what kind of hens each fox most wants to eat.”

David Stockman (former Reagan budget advisor): “[T]he Republican Party was hijacked by modern imperialists during the Reagan era. As a consequence, the conservative party cannot perform its natural function as watchdog of the public purse because it is constantly seeking legislative action to provision a vast war machine of invasion and occupation.”

Our technology and progress are due to scientists. Repugs are science deniers.

Trump is dismantling the EPA.

Trump and the Republicans want more tax cuts for the the rich, despite record concentration of wealth.

Yet almost half the electorate are brainwashed into electing an obviously incompetent and unstable conman as president. So the problem is not just Trump.  The problem is the conservative movement and the right wing media and billionaires that fund it.

Conservative logic

Women: “Can I have birth control?”
Republicans: “No.”

Women: “I couldn’t get birth control so I got pregnant. Can I have an abortion?”
Republicans: “No.”

Women: “I had the baby, but I’m out of work. Can I have WIC and food stamps until I get back on my feet?”
Republicans: “No.”

Women: “I found a job, but it doesn’t offer me insurance. Can I have government guaranteed insurance?”
Republicans: “No.”

Women: “My kid got sick and I got fired because I missed time caring for him. Can I get unemployment?”
Republicans: “No.”

Women: “I’m having a hard time getting my kid from school consistently. Can we fund after-school programs?”
Republicans: “No.”

Women: I’m prepared to work to support my family. Can you make sure that a full-time job’s minimum wage is enough to do that?
Republicans: No. But what’s the matter with you and your family, that working two jobs can’t lift you out of poverty? And can’t you keep your kids off the street? Oh, and make sure they’re doing well in school.